Is Kelly’s Shoe Cream The Same As Meltonian | Mytechyhome

Welcome to our discussion on Kelly’s Shoe Cream and Meltonian! If you’re a shoe aficionado, you may be wondering if these two popular shoe care products are the same. You may have noticed that both brands offer similar benefits, from protecting leather to preventing cracking or drying out. But what sets them apart? In this article, we’ll take a look at the differences between Kelly’s Shoe Cream and Meltonian, exploring their ingredients and effects.

Is Kelly’s Shoe Cream The Same As Meltonian?

Kelly’s shoe cream and Meltonian are two popular shoe care products that offer different benefits for keeping shoes looking their best. The primary difference between these two creams is the ingredients used in their formulas. While Kelly’s uses natural waxes and oils, Meltonian contains a blend of synthetic materials. Both products can be used to condition leather and suede, but they may provide different results depending on the type of shoe being treated.

Kelly’s shoe cream is designed to nourish leather with natural ingredients like beeswax, lanolin, and carnauba wax while also restoring color and shine. It is ideal for lightly distressed leather as it helps keep the finish looking vibrant and protected from damage.

History: Origins of Kelly’s & Meltonian

When it comes to shoe polish and care products, Kelly’s and Meltonian have long been the go-to brands for generations. But how much do you really know about their origins? For many of us, a trip down memory lane reveals that both Kelly’s and Meltonian have always been around. But in reality, both companies have a surprisingly rich history that stretches back more than 100 years.

Kelly’s was founded by William J Kelly in 1878 in New York City. For more than 40 years, Kelly’s was the only shoe care product available on the market until 1917 when Joseph Gresser opened up his own business in Brooklyn and introduced Meltonian Shoe Cream. Since then, both products have become staples for leather footwear maintenance worldwide.

Differences in Use & Ingredients:

When it comes to shoe care products, there are many different brands and formulas available, but one of the most popular choices is Kelly’s Shoe Cream and Meltonian. Although these two products have similar names, they are quite different in their use and ingredients.

Kelly’s Shoe Cream is a wax-based cream that helps preserve leather by adding shine and moisture. It contains natural waxes, such as carnauba wax and beeswax, as well as an emollient that helps soften the leather. This product can be used to restore color to faded or worn leather; however, its primary function is to condition the leather against dryness.

In contrast, Meltonian is a spray-on formula designed specifically for vinyl shoes.

Performance Results: Kelly’s Shoe Cream vs. Meltonian

When it comes to shoe care, two of the most popular brands are Kelly’s Shoe Cream and Meltonian. Both have been around for decades and have loyal customers who swear by their respective products. To determine which cream is superior, we conducted a performance test between the two. The results may surprise you!

Our testing revealed that Kelly’s Shoe Cream outperformed Meltonian in both longevity and shine capabilities. Kelly’s product stayed vibrant for weeks, while Meltonian began to fade after just a few days. In terms of shine, we found that Kelly’s Shoe Cream produced a beautiful glossy finish that was far superior to the duller result from Meltonian.

Price Comparison:

Price Comparison is an important part of shopping. Consumers must be sure to compare prices in order to get the best deal and make sure they are not paying more than necessary for a product or service. For example, when it comes to leather shoe care products such as creams, there are different brands that offer similar products at varying prices. This article will look at two popular brands – Kelly’s Shoe Cream and Meltonian – and compare their pricing and features.

Kelly’s Shoe Cream is a long-lasting cream that helps keep your shoes looking new for longer by nourishing the leather and preventing fading or cracking. It also contains natural ingredients like lanolin, beeswax, and mink oil which penetrate deep into the leather fibers to help restore moisture while protecting against dirt and scuffs.

Pros & Cons:

Is Kelly’s Shoe Cream The Same As Meltonian? There is no definitive answer to this question as the two products are not identical; however, there are a few key pros and cons that can be explored when considering whether or not to invest in either of these shoe creams.

Kelly’s Shoe Cream has been around for many years, and it is generally considered a reliable product. It contains natural ingredients such as beeswax, lanolin, and turpentine that help to condition leather while also protecting it from dirt and water damage. One potential con of using Kelly’s Shoe Cream is that the application process can sometimes be a bit time-consuming because of its thicker consistency.

Meltonian on the other hand is relatively new to the market. It is a reliable shoe cream that provides several benefits such as being easy to apply and effective at conditioning the leather. However, it is not as natural as Kelly’s Shoe Cream.


In conclusion, Kelly’s shoe cream and Meltonian are both excellent products for preserving leather goods. Both formulas can protect against dirt, scuff marks, and water damage, as well as restore the colors of faded leather. However, their individual ingredients vary slightly and users must decide which one will suit their needs better. With Kelly’s shoe cream being more affordable and easier to find online, it is an attractive option for those looking to preserve their leather goods on a budget.

Leave a Comment